Category: Review

  • Ian McDonald’s Brasyl, Science Fiction, and Music

    I don’t know why, but my segment for the third Georgia Tech Sci-Fi Lab Radio Show wasn’t aired.  I listened to the show, and it was well done and had some good interviews.  Kinda sucks that I didn’t make it into the mix, but what can you do?  What I can do is post it here in text (below) and mp4 audio (here) for your reading/listening pleasure.  Enjoy!

    Good evening.  This is Jason Ellis bringing you another Science Fiction review.  I’m a PhD candidate at Kent State University, an alumnus of Georgia Tech, and a former SF Lab fellow.  Tonight, I’m reading a review of Ian McDonald’s Brasyl, spelled B-R-A-S-Y-L, which was originally published in SFRA Review number 281.  Also, I will talk about Brasyl’s connection to music, as well as the relationship between SF texts and music in general.  Let’s begin.

    Ian McDonald hacks reality in his latest novel, Brasyl.  It’s a postcolonial cyberpunk SF story that goes far beyond The Matrix.  Instead of humanity being plugged into a network run by a powerful machine intelligence, humanity and what we believe to be reality are merely bits flipping in the grand simulation memory of the largest of all possible computers:  the multiverse, parallel universes amounting to the sum of all possibilities.  The author combines Nick Bostrom’s philosophy of living within a computer simulation and Stephen Wolfram’s mathematical cellular automata with the latest developments in quantum theory to enact this paradigm shifting SF story.

    McDonald begins developing the reader’s estrangement by subtly disconnecting the naming of Brazil from its accepted origins while accurately and poetically constructing a past, present, and future space instantly recognized as Brazil.  It’s interesting that McDonald titled the novel Brasyl, which is the Erse word for “land of the blest,” according to Arthur Percival Newton in his 1970 work, The Great Age of Discovery.  Also, this name is connected to the Irish myth about a hidden island known as “Hy-Brazil.”  This sets the land and its name apart from the more accepted etymology of Brazil, which derives from “brasil,” the Portuguese word for embers originally used to describe red brazil wood.

    The story follows three emblematic protagonists in different times and universes, but all orbiting the physical space known as Brazil.  Football (i.e., soccer, not American football) is juxtaposed with religion, renaissance science, reality TV, and quantum theory to create a colorful rendition of Brazil.  What is that space?  Who are its inhabitants?  What groups desire to control the mythically lost island as well as the quantum nature of reality of which Brazil serves as locus?

    It’s the quantum nature of reality that’s the constant in the equation of Brasyl.  Within the narrative, a struggle exists between the Order, a group of quantum reality aware persons who dogmatically believe that parallel universes should be left alone to run unabated, and another group of freedom minded people who’ve learned how to hack reality, because reality is nothing more than a complex simulation running across all possible universes.  This conflict is played out in 1732 with the Irish Jesuit priest, Father Luis Quinn, 2006 with the reality TV producer Marcelina Hoffman, and 2032 with the bisexual, role assuming businessman, Edson Jesus Oliveira de Freitas.  The battle that Luis, Marcelina, and Edson find themselves in mirrors the history of Brazil and the historic conflicts fueled by religious evangelism and conversion, usurping resources from the land and people, and control of a country carved out of the Amazon similarly to the Congo in Joseph Conrad’s The Heart of Darkness (1902).  The rewards for those who wish to strike out from the simulation means the creation of something new and exploring a life not yet played through several times over.

    Appropriately enough, the most significant hack is the re-creation of the Estádio do Maracanã in Rio de Janeiro.  Therein lies the heart of McDonald’s postcolonial thesis.  Football, originally a European sport, is appropriated by Brazil and is subsequently integrated into Brazilian national identity.  They took a European (i.e., the colonizer) sport and improved upon it by developing arguably the best football players in the world.  Analogously, quantum theory originated in the minds of European and American thinkers (i.e., the power elite of the Northern hemisphere).  Again, quantum theory and its many strange ways are unraveled and utilized to recreate something close to the heart of Brazilian national culture.

    Brasyl continues McDonald’s record as both an SF writer of postcolonial narratives and a first rate author.  He recreates the richness of Brazil in this novel by sampling its language and history.  Also, he provides a useful glossary at the end of the text to assist readers with Brazilian words.  The author proves that estrangement from the Western norm need not take place on other planets or between the stars.  He poetically constructs the story and setting for Brasyl as beautifully and expertly as he does in other works such as the “Chaga Saga” including Evolution’s Shore (1995), Kirinya (1998), and Tendeléo’s Story (2000), which is set in Kenya.  Another recognized work by McDonald in the same vein as Brasyl is River of Gods (2006), which is set in India.  Just as connections may be drawn between River of Gods and Salman Rushdie’s Midnight’s Children (1981), it’s the author’s striking descriptions, metaphor, and pacing in their works that unite the talents of these two authors.  Not only is Brasyl a powerful work of SF, it’s also a fine work of literature.

    McDonald employs good scientific theory and an artful explanation of the quantum nature of reality and quantum computing necessary for the reader to see the underlying processes in the story as more than magical effects.  His making Brazil central to the battle for quantum reality is artfully accomplished via the Amazonian curupairá, a golden frog that secretes a chemical that empowers individuals to see the vastness of quantum reality.  Additionally, his depiction of hopping worlds echoes David Gerrold’s The Man Who Folded Himself (1973).

    The novel’s cyberpunk connections come from the technology employed by particularly characters.  The parallel 2032 world is featured as one vision of a cyberpunk world.  Edson has a pair of I-shades, which are heads-up display computers that connect to a network of overflowing information more vast than our current Internet but recalling the ubiquity of information in John Brunner’s The Shockwave Rider (1975).  His dead girlfriend’s doppelganger, the “other” Fia, comes from a parallel world where computers are integrated into our flesh as animated full body tattoos.  Edson’s Brazil is a world of complete surveillance and RFID chips that give away one’s movements and habits much like Stephen Spielberg’s Minority Report (2002), unless of course you’re as resourceful and enterprising as Edson.  However, McDonald breaks with earlier cyberpunk stories in that the quantum computers Edson steals are tools used for various real-world purposes rather than eye candy.

    Ian McDonald’s Brasyl is a significant work of SF deserving critical and academic attention.  The novel would be easily integrated into undergraduate postcolonial and philosophy reading lists.  Additionally, librarians should stock this title for the independent research that it will undoubtedly garner.  The author is at the top of his craft with Brasyl and I can sense my many other selves in parallel universes equally shouting its praises!

    Now, what does this text and other SF works have to do with music?  In this case, the author includes a playlist in the book’s appendix that includes twenty songs by Brazilian artists, most of which are available on the iTunes music store.  It begins with the percussive “No Tranco” by Siri, progreses through the electric stylings of Mylene’s “Nela Lagoa,” and ends with a late song by Milton Nascimento called, “O Cio da terra.”  This playlist is important to “getting” the novel, because the author drowns the reader in Brazilian past, present, and future.  Music provides a convenient and emotive avenue for the author to plunge the reader into something familiar, but different.  In this regard, music can be read as a cognitively estranging enterprise.

    Kathleen Ann Goonan works a similar magic in her Nanotech series beginning with Queen City Jazz.  Music is integral to the story as well as the way in which the author tells the story.  Goonan writes in her essay, “Science Fiction and All That Jazz,” which you can read on her website at http://www.goonan.com, “So how do music and science fiction mesh?  Art is conscious human design — as in technology, music, or literature — that takes what is available to experience and the senses and transforms it into something useful, beautiful, or both. Fiction’s deep rhythms demand tales of human change. Art is an attempt to defy, at least momentarily, the heat-death of the universe, to pluck random elements from the materials at hand and give them an arrow of time and a satisfying (if often edgy) order. To meld two major musical and literary ideas of the twentieth century, to portray human change in a technological, if musical, milieu, seems to me to be an interesting and almost inevitable enterprise.”  Therefore, the co-evolution and technological mediation taking place in SF and music leads to the co-creation and integration of works involving both.

    Another SF story that fuses text with music is Ursula K. Le Guin’s 1985 work, Always Coming Home.  Le Guin does something different than McDonald and Goonan by creating new works of music specifically for her novel.  She worked with Todd Barton to create songs and poetry of the fictional Kesh people.  The resulting collaboration is included with the first edition as a bundled audiocassette.  This additional dimension to the text contained in the novel elevates Always Coming Home to a higher level of anthropological SF that Le Guin is well known for.

    Music and SF are inextricably linked.  In fact, music is like the force from Star Wars.  Obi-Wan Kenobi describes it as, “an energy field, created by all living things, that surrounds us, penetrates us, and binds the galaxy together.”  Music does this too, and through it, it acts as another layer, another strata of networks connecting readers and authors, works and the world.

    Thanks for listening, and find out more about my take on SF criticism by visiting my blog, dynamicsubspace.net.

  • Galaxy Quest and Fandom

    This is my second review segment for the Georgia Tech SF Radio Program. The theme of this episode is fandom, so I reviewed the film, Galaxy Quest and related that to the rise of fandom. Be sure to check out the show on Sunday, September 23 from 7pm until 9pm. Listen to it in Atlanta on 91.1FM or online at wrek.org.

    Galaxy Quest and Fandom
    Jason W. Ellis

    Science Fiction has a long standing dialog between SF producers and the fans that follow, devour, and over analyze every detail and plot point of their respective SF love. This is proven by the early New York City Futurians and SF conventions or “cons” that accreted greater and greater numbers of SF readers, writers, and enthusiasts. This subculture of SF enthusiasts is known as fandom. Members of SF fandom go by different names including Trekkies, Browncoats, Whovians, and Otaku. However, that’s not to say it’s a subculture on the fringe in terms of numbers. In fact, fandom has gone mainstream. The larger national and international conventions such as Atlanta’s own Dragon*Con hosts an influx of tens and tens of thousands of SF fans to share something unknown, or at least unknown in the same magnitude and intensity, to the majority of pop culture consumers, and that is community.

    In many ways, fandom hit the mainstream with the 1999 release of Galaxy Quest. This film starring Tim Allen, Alan Rickman, Sigourney Weaver, and Tony Shalhoub is about the washed-up cast of a late 1970s SF television show rising up to their fictional roles following an unexpected alien encounter. These aliens, called Thermians, contact Jason Nesmith (played by Tim Allen) believing that he is his fictional television role, Captain Peter Quincy Taggart. These naive aliens regard intercepted human television transmissions as “historical documents” and utilize them to rebuild their society. However, their new civilization is threatened by the reptilian Sarris, the genocidal leader of a warring alien species. The real life actors portraying film actors in turn portray the fictionalized crew of the Thermian constructed NSEA Protector in order to stop Sarris’ plans to obliterate the remaining Thermians.

    Galaxy Quest has a deep connection to fandom, because a group of Questarians, or fans of the old television show (think Trekkies), assist the real life Protector crew with the help of a serendipitous exchange of authentic and prop communicators. Justin Long portrays the de facto leader, Brandon, of a band of Questarians. They rely on social networking and pooled, specialized knowledge to help Taggart and his crew. In the end, these die hard fans are as much the heroes as the TV stars, in part because they are both on the big screen, but also because fans are the driving force behind SF. They keep it alive and elevate it to mythic status by the communal sharing of ideas, stories, costumes, fan films, fanfic, and lest we forget, commercialization.

    There are many other aspects of fandom in film such as the 1998 film, Free Enterprise. Directed by Robert Meyer Burnett, it’s about two friends clinging to their SF geek interests while seeking life advice of their hero, William Shatner. Another film about fan life is the forthcoming 5-25-77 written and directed by Patrick Read Johnson. It’s an autobiographical take on the fateful day that the original Star Wars film was released. In both of these examples, the SF source (not to be confused with force) supports the release–in the case of the former with a starring role by Shatner and the latter is produced by Gary Kurtz, who also produced two Star Wars films.

    Fans also create parodies and original works based on the SF sources they love most. A famous example is Samuli Tors-sonen’s Finnish Star Wreck films including the immensely popular Star Wreck: In the Pirkinning released in 2005. In the Pirkinning is a feature length film complete with professional special effects and it’s an mash-up of Star Trek and Babylon 5. Other examples of fan films include Troops, the 1997 mockumentary mix-up of Star Wars and COPS. More recent examples include Star Wars: Revelations and Chad Vader.

    Underlying fandom, fan films, and SF in general are fans. They are the immediate audience for new SF produced by writers and film makers as well as fan produced content available online. They’ve always been there, and they are making their voices heard more loudly than ever before thanks to the increasingly pervasive Internet, which has not only facilitated the building of fan communities, but also the sharing of rich and imaginative content made for other fans and as an homage to the creators on high. In the coming years, the division between fans and creators will further diminish, and I say to all the fans out there, the immortal words of Captain Taggert: “Never give up, never surrender!”

  • Ian McDonald’s Brasyl

    Ian McDonald’s latest novel, Brasyl, is a superb work of literary fiction as well as postcolonial SF. It’s about the quantum nature of parallel worlds and how those parallel worlds are actually simulations running on a computer spanning the entire universe. Centered in Brazil, it takes place in three different times, but not linearly connected in the same parallel universe. The three protagonists discover threats to a freedom more basic than that described in The Matrix, and they fight their own overlapping battles to challenge the dogma of quantum time line unalterableness.

    I highly recommend this novel for the story, the author’s superior word choice and style, and the postcolonial message lying just beneath the surface of observable reality. For a more through review, check out my piece in the upcoming SFRA Review.

  • Transformers Review

    Michael Bay’s latest SF film, Transformers (2007), is a slick and action packed summer blockbuster brimming with special effects that succeeds in ways that I had not expected it to do so. Of course, there are the obligatory cheesy lines, full-frontal scenes of people running away from something insanely scary right on their tail, and massive explosions and demolition. Luckily, the film goes beyond its clichés and one liners. On the surface, the film is about a one-dimensional conflict between the good Autobots who serve as humanity’s protectors and the evil Decepticons who aspire to kill and destroy on the path to the life generating “Cube.” However, the film is about much more than meets the eye.

    The film begins with American soldiers in Iraq returning from a patrol to their base where their fellow soldiers are working, showering, and playing basketball. This peaceful scene of Army life is soon shattered as the Decepticon Blackout and his passenger Scorponok descend into the camp disguised as a Sikorsky helicopter. The camp is decimated and only our returning patrol heroes live to escape and fight another day.

    This crew led by Captain Lennox (Josh Duhamel) eventually kill Scorponok with the help of a laser guided air strike and they are recalled to the United States for a full debriefing. However, their return to the States results in the war, once thought of as “over there,” being transfered to the American homeland.

    These soldiers fight along side the good robots called Autobots, who are led by Optimus Prime (Peter Cullen). They find themselves fighting the powerful Decepticons who are led by Megatron (Hugo Weaving). Belying the fact that these American soldiers are fighting killer robots, is that they are fighting a war against an enemy that can blend into its surroundings. The enemy is literally a transformer–capable of transforming from the obvious threat of a giant, intelligent robot to something dangerous yet less threatening due to its terrestrial origins such as a tank, helicopter, plane, cell phone, or boom box (the latter two examples conjure the invasion of the camera phone and spying and the boom box is the harbinger of subversive music).

    Even more problematic than the metamorphosis of these giant robots is that the battle is shifted from Iraq (i.e., somewhere else) to America (i.e., the untouched, virginal homeland). The battle between Autobots and Decepticons took place long ago on their obliterated homeplanet, Cybertron. Now, they have brought their fight here to Earth in search of the Cube, an artifact capable of creating artificial life. The Autobots have a noble mission to prevent the Decepticons from obtaining the Cube while protecting humanity in its, to their perspective, infancy. This maps onto American’s own involvement in wars such as Afghanistan and Iraq. In the former, we set out to remove the Taliban from power and in the latter, to depose Saddam Hussein. In both cases, American forces remain to preserve stability and fight off insurgent forces (human transformers). Ultimately, these foreign battles are revisited on America in the mythical “Mission City” where Sam Witwicky (Shia Labeouf) aided by Bubblebee are to hide the Cube. The Decepticons arrive en force to wreak havoc on their way to taking the Cube from the Autobots’ and humanity’s protection. There are telling shots of Megatron and Starscream, both capable of flight, of going through some of the city’s highrise buildings much as the planes of the 9/11 Attacks did in 2001.

    These attacks culminate with Sam saving the day, but without truly up-holding his family’s motto, “no sacrifice, no victory.” In the end, one Autobot has been killed, but the central cast has survived and his family is assumed to be in the care of the government. Optimus Prime tries to be the sacrifice to save humanity from the voracity of the Decepticons (and he says this several times during the film), but it’s Sam final decision that saves Prime and humanity from an untimely end. Sam, as the prototypical American hero not by brawn but my family heritage and therefore history, represents a failure in fulfilling his family motto which is as much an American belief system as it is his family’s motto. Thus, the motto and what it represents breaks down in the face of the movie’s conclusion just as American triumphalism gave way to the American identity crisis during the Cold War. I would like to note that there are other ways of reading the ending of the film, but I don’t want to go into further details without giving away anything beyond the movie’s obvious ending.

    Transformers is an enjoyable SF film that actually carries a bigger message than robot warriors are destined to fight while dragging humanity along for the ride. For the naysayers who decry the Autobots’ naivety and simplicity in the film, I direct them to watch the Saturday morning cartoons of the 1980s where they’ll find Bay has kept much closer to the source material than one might wish to believe he had. The film updates the core story with contemporary issues and the latest in transportation developments since the cartoon first debuted in 1984. I recommend the movie as both an SF film worthy of a second look and as a summer blockbuster complete with the “transforming sound” and Peter Cullen’s distinctive voice as Optimus Prime.

    Visit the official site for more information, and check out the film’s trailers here.

  • Ian R. MacLeod’s “The Summer Isles”

    Ian R. MacLeod’s “The Summer Isles” first appeared in Asimov’s Science Fiction in October/November 1998. It’s a very well written and helical alternative history narrative about how things could have gone terribly awry in Britain had they lost World War I. MacLeod shows off his literary talents in this novella.

    The story is told from the point of view of a historian and professor at Oxford University who once knew Britain’s leader, though by a much different name and personality. The Great War changed his former lover into something perverted in a way much more real and worthy of concern than what tightly wound conservatives might think. The story deals with issues made explicit during the Third Reich in Germany, but MacLeod reveals how those hatreds and misconceptions can be fanned into a fury in places we might least expect it. Additionally, the way he presents the feelings, relationships, and plight of homosexual men in his alternative “brave new world” is expressive yet full of despair and eventually resignation to “do the right thing.”

    The story is more an alternative history than strictly SF, but it’s definitely worth a read. It would probably be an valuable asset in classes dealing with revolution, genocide, and sexual orientation. I found the story in Gardner Dozois’ The Mammoth Book of Best New SF 12, but there’s also a bound edition available–more info on the author’s website here.